Page 1 of 2

Hand Guard Protector vs bar end muff - any wrap around ones?

Posted: Wed Apr 29, 2015 2:46 am
by iceman
There's quite a choice of bar end muffs to help protect against the winter chill and frozen fingers - some just slip over and others fit to the bar end's themselves, but I wonder if anyone knows of hand guard protectors that sort of wrap around above and under the fingers more than the usual types. The more area protected from the wind the better, and I figure less easy for people to swipe than muffs when the bike is left parked for some time.
A fairly decent hand guard (for area covered) and cheap seems to be:
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Universal-Mot ... 418ab48505
One that covers a lot of area, looks nice but may not fit the PCX and is very costly - 339 euro's! (no intention of buying this!!!) is:
http://www.mv-motorrad.de/en/R1200GS+up ... rs+Set.htm
Or you can get ones, again maybe not universal fit for PCX but includes extra lights is:
http://www.fc-moto.de/Acerbis-Vision-Handprotektoren
I've searched google / Ebay, etc, but can't seem to find guards that offer slightly more above/under protection from the wind - seems a bit strange they do not add a few extra inches of cover for little extra cost.

Re: Hand Guard Protector vs bar end muff - any wrap around o

Posted: Wed Apr 29, 2015 3:03 am
by DAB
I have fitted Storm handguards, excellent fit. Got heated grips and grip puppies to fit in the near future.

Re: Hand Guard Protector vs bar end muff - any wrap around o

Posted: Wed Apr 29, 2015 8:21 am
by iceman
Thanks DAB. Something like this:
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/BARKBUSTERS-S ... 1815045900
A bit expensive and not sure if this is the one that will fit. From experience, would this be enough to help with frozen fingers at city speeds (30-40mph) wearing just thick motorcycle gloves? If not, I may opt for bar-end mounted bar mitts.
Thanks!

Re: Hand Guard Protector vs bar end muff - any wrap around o

Posted: Wed Apr 29, 2015 11:02 am
by WhiteNoise
Iceman, of the ones you posted I like the Acerbis vision. Why not take advantage of the 2 benefits? With Protection of hands and "see me, see onward" bonus lighting? Unless you or anyone thinks the lighting sits too high that it might annoy vehicles in front of you and oncoming? Hmm :roll: How would you wire them up? They have a bar switch as well. I like them 8)

DAB, When you do fit those "grip puppies," can you post about how you did it & how easy or hard it was to get them on? Technique or whatever it took? I have a pair of them sitting around ( :? so much stuff, now where did I put them?) waiting to get fitted. I've been wondering IF I should do it or not. Do we destroy our grips in the process? Geez, I've had these too long lying round (yeah, someplace) I forgot :roll:

Excuse me iceman for trailing off topic. I be bad

Re: Hand Guard Protector vs bar end muff - any wrap around o

Posted: Wed Apr 29, 2015 1:20 pm
by iceman
WhiteNoise wrote:Excuse me iceman for trailing off topic. I be bad
Your not off topic and no need to apolgise. :)

Re: Hand Guard Protector vs bar end muff - any wrap around o

Posted: Wed Apr 29, 2015 2:23 pm
by DAB
iceman wrote:Thanks DAB. Something like this:
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/BARKBUSTERS-S ... 1815045900
A bit expensive and not sure if this is the one that will fit. From experience, would this be enough to help with frozen fingers at city speeds (30-40mph) wearing just thick motorcycle gloves? If not, I may opt for bar-end mounted bar mitts.
Thanks!
Go to the Barkbuster website and the version for the PCX is listed. They fit on the bar end only. Keeps your fingers dry when its raining.

Re: Hand Guard Protector vs bar end muff - any wrap around o

Posted: Wed Apr 29, 2015 2:34 pm
by DAB
WhiteNoise wrote:Iceman, of the ones you posted I like the Acerbis vision. Why not take advantage of the 2 benefits? With Protection of hands and "see me, see onward" bonus lighting? Unless you or anyone thinks the lighting sits too high that it might annoy vehicles in front of you and oncoming? Hmm :roll: How would you wire them up? They have a bar switch as well. I like them 8)

DAB, When you do fit those "grip puppies," can you post about how you did it & how easy or hard it was to get them on? Technique or whatever it took? I have a pair of them sitting around ( :? so much stuff, now where did I put them?) waiting to get fitted. I've been wondering IF I should do it or not. Do we destroy our grips in the process? Geez, I've had these too long lying round (yeah, someplace) I forgot :roll:

Excuse me iceman for trailing off topic. I be bad
The puppies go over your existing grips so no destruction. I stretched them a little by inserting a plug socket inside. Used a little WD40 on the grips and slid the little beggers on. I found that it was easier to pull them on rather than push. That is stand on the left hand side to install the right grip.
The main reason for installing these was to have a greater diameter grip rather than for vibration damping.

Re: Hand Guard Protector vs bar end muff - any wrap around o

Posted: Wed Apr 29, 2015 3:51 pm
by you you
DAB wrote:
WhiteNoise wrote:Iceman, of the ones you posted I like the Acerbis vision. Why not take advantage of the 2 benefits? With Protection of hands and "see me, see onward" bonus lighting? Unless you or anyone thinks the lighting sits too high that it might annoy vehicles in front of you and oncoming? Hmm :roll: How would you wire them up? They have a bar switch as well. I like them 8)

DAB, When you do fit those "grip puppies," can you post about how you did it & how easy or hard it was to get them on? Technique or whatever it took? I have a pair of them sitting around ( :? so much stuff, now where did I put them?) waiting to get fitted. I've been wondering IF I should do it or not. Do we destroy our grips in the process? Geez, I've had these too long lying round (yeah, someplace) I forgot :roll:

Excuse me iceman for trailing off topic. I be bad
The puppies go over your existing grips so no destruction. I stretched them a little by inserting a plug socket inside. Used a little WD40 on the grips and slid the little beggers on. I found that it was easier to pull them on rather than push. That is stand on the left hand side to install the right grip.
The main reason for installing these was to have a greater diameter grip rather than for vibration damping.

I love puppies. Any pictures?

Re: Hand Guard Protector vs bar end muff - any wrap around o

Posted: Wed Apr 29, 2015 11:12 pm
by WhiteNoise
iceman, Thanx :) Did you choose any yet?

DAB, really? WD40? hmm, kinda stinky for my leather gloves to soak up :? Are you joking with me?
I seem to recall reading something about using very soapy water? Okay, stand on opposite side and pull on. Good 2 know, and YES, I bought the pups for the very same reason, to enlarge grip diameter. Thanks for the tips and your quick reply! :P

2yous, how are ya? Raining these days? I know you like puppies. So lovable. Heh now, ya got a Pet Store near? AWESOME!! Go buys one. Yeah, take a youngin' home. Give him a hug :D

Oh Dear...I did it again! Sorry twice iceman :oops:

Topic is Hand Guard Protector vs Bar End Muff. I still like the lit ones :D

Re: Hand Guard Protector vs bar end muff - any wrap around o

Posted: Wed Apr 29, 2015 11:51 pm
by DAB
WhiteNoise wrote:iceman, Thanx :) Did you choose any yet?

DAB, really? WD40? hmm, kinda stinky for my leather gloves to soak up :? Are you joking with me?
I seem to recall reading something about using very soapy water? Okay, stand on opposite side and pull on. Good 2 know, and YES, I bought the pups for the very same reason, to enlarge grip diameter. Thanks for the tips and your quick reply! :P

2yous, how are ya? Raining these days? I know you like puppies. So lovable. Heh now, ya got a Pet Store near? AWESOME!! Go buys one. Yeah, take a youngin' home. Give him a hug :D

Oh Dear...I did it again! Sorry twice iceman :oops:

Topic is Hand Guard Protector vs Bar End Muff. I still like the lit ones :D
I used WD40 which was sprayed on the original grips, you could use soapy water.

Re: Hand Guard Protector vs bar end muff - any wrap around o

Posted: Fri May 01, 2015 4:44 am
by iceman
Well, damn loctite has so far defeated me and friends who aided in trying to get the damn bar ends off.
I borrowed an impact driver and used a large hammer weighing about 1 KG, and despite many attempts the only result is one screw with slight knurled edges on the thread, the other with a bit of paint off and a bit of blood drawn on the umpteenth swing of the hammer. Neither screw has budged in the slightest!
So, next I'll try a rotating half lever and bit from a socket set. If that does not work guess I'll give up. Why did they have to be fixed so tightly - a bit of glue would be enough, if any is really necessary!!!

Re: Hand Guard Protector vs bar end muff - any wrap around o

Posted: Fri May 01, 2015 9:49 am
by you you
WhiteNoise wrote:iceman, Thanx :) Did you choose any yet?

DAB, really? WD40? hmm, kinda stinky for my leather gloves to soak up :? Are you joking with me?
I seem to recall reading something about using very soapy water? Okay, stand on opposite side and pull on. Good 2 know, and YES, I bought the pups for the very same reason, to enlarge grip diameter. Thanks for the tips and your quick reply! :P

2yous, how are ya? Raining these days? I know you like puppies. So lovable. Heh now, ya got a Pet Store near? AWESOME!! Go buys one. Yeah, take a youngin' home. Give him a hug :D

Oh Dear...I did it again! Sorry twice iceman :oops:

Topic is Hand Guard Protector vs Bar End Muff. I still like the lit ones :D
Strangely enough it hasnt rained in the centre of the universe for a while. Rivers are starting to get very shallow

Re: Hand Guard Protector vs bar end muff - any wrap around o

Posted: Thu May 07, 2015 6:32 am
by iceman
iceman wrote:Well, damn loctite has so far defeated me and friends who aided in trying to get the damn bar ends off.
I borrowed an impact driver and used a large hammer weighing about 1 KG, and despite many attempts the only result is one screw with slight knurled edges on the thread, the other with a bit of paint off and a bit of blood drawn on the umpteenth swing of the hammer. Neither screw has budged in the slightest!
So, next I'll try a rotating half lever and bit from a socket set. If that does not work guess I'll give up. Why did they have to be fixed so tightly - a bit of glue would be enough, if any is really necessary!!!
Four of us had another go at this with the bike preped against a wall (one end of handlebars with glove over) and 2ft angled leverage with proper fitting screw end to remove the opposite bar-end screw (as impact driver did not work). Result is - screws did not move or get any worse for wear but the screw bit twisted so that it now has about a 10 deg twist! So, now given up as cannot get the ends off without perhaps drilling out an inch or so of screw, removing the bar end (if possible) thus leaving an inch of bare screw to turn. The glue used seems stronger than the steel of the bit!

Re: Hand Guard Protector vs bar end muff - any wrap around o

Posted: Thu May 07, 2015 7:20 am
by DAB
Iceman, what type of impact driver did you use? You need and electrical one and not one that you hit with an hammer.

Re: Hand Guard Protector vs bar end muff - any wrap around o

Posted: Thu May 07, 2015 11:10 am
by iceman
Used a manual one. Hope they are standard thread and not clockwise to loosen :)

Re: Hand Guard Protector vs bar end muff - any wrap around o

Posted: Thu May 07, 2015 3:40 pm
by you you
iceman wrote:
iceman wrote:Well, damn loctite has so far defeated me and friends who aided in trying to get the damn bar ends off.
I borrowed an impact driver and used a large hammer weighing about 1 KG, and despite many attempts the only result is one screw with slight knurled edges on the thread, the other with a bit of paint off and a bit of blood drawn on the umpteenth swing of the hammer. Neither screw has budged in the slightest!
So, next I'll try a rotating half lever and bit from a socket set. If that does not work guess I'll give up. Why did they have to be fixed so tightly - a bit of glue would be enough, if any is really necessary!!!
Four of us had another go at this with the bike preped against a wall (one end of handlebars with glove over) and 2ft angled leverage with proper fitting screw end to remove the opposite bar-end screw (as impact driver did not work). Result is - screws did not move or get any worse for wear but the screw bit twisted so that it now has about a 10 deg twist! So, now given up as cannot get the ends off without perhaps drilling out an inch or so of screw, removing the bar end (if possible) thus leaving an inch of bare screw to turn. The glue used seems stronger than the steel of the bit!

Did you try putting the bit in the screw and giving it a couple of good cracks with a hammer to free any locking compound or corrosion?

Re: Hand Guard Protector vs bar end muff - any wrap around o

Posted: Thu May 07, 2015 11:19 pm
by iceman
Yes, did that with the manual impact driver using a 1KG hammer. Not budged one bit. The screw bit that got twisted is part of a set my mate has had for years and used for all kinds of car/bike maintenance - only this time did any of it suffer any kind of damage. Not sure he's more upset about the damaged part of failing to get the screws out - he does not like being defeated :)
Neither screw on each side seems to have moved at all - just starting to show signs of wear around the edges of the screw heads.
I think I will go with non-bar end muff cuffs (!!) or those and handle bar fixing hand guards (just to help stop wind, not protection).
I've got layered gloves for cold/wet which helps to some extent - but they start getting too bulky. Really wanted to stop the wind in near zero or sub-zero temps which I thought hand guards help achieve.

Re: Hand Guard Protector vs bar end muff - any wrap around o

Posted: Fri May 08, 2015 1:16 am
by you you
iceman wrote:Yes, did that with the manual impact driver using a 1KG hammer. Not budged one bit. The screw bit that got twisted is part of a set my mate has had for years and used for all kinds of car/bike maintenance - only this time did any of it suffer any kind of damage. Not sure he's more upset about the damaged part of failing to get the screws out - he does not like being defeated :)
Neither screw on each side seems to have moved at all - just starting to show signs of wear around the edges of the screw heads.
I think I will go with non-bar end muff cuffs (!!) or those and handle bar fixing hand guards (just to help stop wind, not protection).
I've got layered gloves for cold/wet which helps to some extent - but they start getting too bulky. Really wanted to stop the wind in near zero or sub-zero temps which I thought hand guards help achieve.

Think I'd try the releasing oil next. Repeated over a week or so. Make a pair of plasticine or tape oil "cups" and leave overnight

Re: Hand Guard Protector vs bar end muff - any wrap around o

Posted: Fri May 08, 2015 3:08 am
by DAB
Iceman, The S7 handguards are very good and well worth the effort to install. You need to use a electrical impact driver, also if the bit twisted you are not using the correct bit as impact bits shatter rather than bend. Can't imagine releasing oil will do any good.

Re: Hand Guard Protector vs bar end muff - any wrap around o

Posted: Fri May 08, 2015 4:23 am
by iceman
Thinking of using a soldering iron to heat the screw up :) - a bit like this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mvlSkFLgnyc